Hand-poured, small-batch slow-rise squishies

Shop by type

Shop All New Arrivals Halloween Butter Classic Butter Sticks Jumbo Butter Loaves Crunch Butter Marble & Swirl Chocolate & Berry Neon Butter Multi-Packs

Popular right now

Halloween Ghost 3-Pack Jumbo Swirl Loaf 14oz Rainbow Stripe Butter Neon Swirl Butter Strawberry Cream Butter

Help Center Track Your Order Contact Us FAQ

EN

USD

Search squishies

Shop

Shop by type Shop All New Arrivals Halloween Butter Classic Butter Sticks Jumbo Butter Loaves Crunch Butter Marble & Swirl Chocolate & Berry Neon Butter Multi-Packs

Popular right now Halloween Ghost 3-Pack Jumbo Swirl Loaf 14oz Rainbow Stripe Butter Neon Swirl Butter Strawberry Cream Butter

Halloween About

Help Center

Help Center Track Your Order Contact Us FAQ

Cart • 0

You're $30 away from FREE shipping

Best price unlocked — you saved $0

Your cart is empty.

Jumbo Butter Loaf 14oz

Jumbo Butter Loaf 14oz Choose a color or style

$1.99 Choose options

butter+

10% off every order
$25 store credit back / month
Cancel anytime

You Save: $0

Learn more about butter+

Most Popular

78% OF CUSTOMERS ALSO BOUGHT:

Halloween Ghost Butter 3-Pack

Halloween Ghost Butter 3-Pack $12.99 Choose options

Halloween Ghost Butter 12-Pack

Halloween Ghost Butter 12-Pack $19.99 Choose options

Rainbow Stripe Butter

Rainbow Stripe Butter $9.99 Choose options

Chocolate Berry Butter 3-Pack

Chocolate Berry Butter 3-Pack $7.99 Choose options

Strawberry Chocolate Butter 4-Pack

Strawberry Chocolate Butter 4-Pack $13.99 Choose options

Sunset Trio Butter 3-Pack

Sunset Trio Butter 3-Pack $8.99 Choose options

Pink Orange Crunch Butter 2-Pack

Pink Orange Crunch Butter 2-Pack $25.99 Choose options

Mint Berry Crunch Butter 2-Pack

Mint Berry Crunch Butter 2-Pack $11.99 Choose options

Continue shopping

✓ Try Risk-Free For 30 Days

Multi-Packs

Filter:

Price

All < $1849 $18 – $256 $25 – $355 $35+3

Sort by:

Featured

Featured Alphabetically, A-Z Alphabetically, Z-A Price, low to high Price, high to low Date, old to new Date, new to old

63 products

Choose options
Blue Butter Stick 2-Pack
$15.99 USD
Choose options
Bread Toast Loaf 2-Pack
$9.99 USD
Choose options
Bread Toast Loaf 2-Pack
$9.99 USD
Choose options
Bread Toast Loaf 4-Pack
$18.99 USD
Choose options
Bread Toast Loaf 9-Pack
$17.98 USD
Choose options
Candy Gradient Butter 2-Pack
$6.99 USD
Choose options
Candy Gradient Butter 3-Pack
$9.99 USD
Choose options
Cheese Cube Loaf 2-Pack
$8.99 USD
Choose options
Cheese Cube Loaf 3-Pack
$15.99 USD
Choose options
Cheese Cube Loaf 3-Pack
$13.99 USD
Choose options
Cheese Cube Loaf 3-Pack
$9.99 USD
Choose options
Cheese Cube Loaf 4-Pack
$16.99 USD
Choose options
Cheese Cube Loaf 4-Pack
$12.99 USD
Choose options
Cheese Cube Loaf 6-Pack
$35.99 USD
Choose options
Chocolate Berry Butter 3-Pack
$7.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Butter Stick 4oz 10-Pack
$34.74 USD
Choose options
Classic Butter Stick 4oz 12-Pack
$30.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Butter Stick 4oz 2-Pack
$4.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Butter Stick 4oz 3-Pack
$6.64 USD
Choose options
Classic Butter Stick 4oz 4-Pack
$7.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Butter Stick 4oz 5-Pack
$12.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Butter Stick 4oz 6-Pack
$12.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Gift Butter 12-Pack
$35.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Gift Butter 2-Pack
$6.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Gift Butter 2-Pack
$9.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Gift Butter 2-Pack
$9.99 USD
Choose options
Classic Gift Butter 2-Pack
$6.99 USD
Choose options
Golden Butter Stick 2-Pack
$14.99 USD
Choose options
Halloween Ghost Butter 12-Pack
$19.99 USD
Choose options
Halloween Ghost Butter 3-Pack
$12.99 USD
Choose options
Jumbo Butter Loaf 14oz 2-Pack
$8.99 USD
Choose options
Jumbo Butter Loaf 14oz 6-Pack
$18.99 USD
Choose options
Lemon Blue Crunch Butter 2-Pack
$25.99 USD
Choose options
Mint Berry Crunch Butter 2-Pack
$11.99 USD
Choose options
Mint Lemon Crunch Butter 2-Pack
$23.99 USD
Choose options
Mixed Butter Pack 2-Pack
$16.98 USD
Choose options
Mixed Butter Pack 3-Pack
$8.99 USD
Choose options
Mixed Butter Pack 4-Pack
$9.99 USD
Choose options
Mixed Butter Pack 4-Pack
$14.99 USD
Choose options
Mixed Butter Pack 5-Pack
$20.99 USD
Choose options
Mixed Butter Pack 5-Pack
$20.99 USD
Choose options
Neon Swirl Butter 12-Pack
$29.99 USD
Choose options
Neon Swirl Butter 18-Pack
$38.99 USD
Choose options
Neon Swirl Butter 2-Pack
$6.99 USD
Choose options
Neon Swirl Butter 3-Pack
$7.99 USD
Choose options
Neon Swirl Butter 4-Pack
$9.99 USD
Choose options
Neon Swirl Butter 6-Pack
$17.99 USD
Choose options
Oil-Paint Swirl Butter 2-Pack
$8.99 USD

Page 1 of 2 Next →

buttersquishy

Need Help?Bundle Builder Help Center FAQs About Wholesale butter+Contact Us Track Your Order Refund / Return Info Shipping Info

Check us outPrivacy Policy Terms of Service Legal Notice

Buttersquishy

Slow-rising squishies that make you smile. From jumbo food squishies to mini animal packs, every Buttersquishy is picked for that perfect soft, satisfying squeeze.

SHOP BY CATEGORY

New Arrivals Halloween Butter Classic Butter Jumbo Butter Crunch Butter Marble Swirl Butter Chocolate Berry Butter Neon Butter Butter Multipacks

PAYMENT METHODS

© 2026, ButtersquishyRefund policy Privacy policy Terms of service Shipping policy

English Deutsch Français Español 日本語 ไทย Polski 한국어 Українська Български 繁體中文 العربية Tiếng Việt Italiano Русский Português Norsk

WhatsApp Support